Back to Blog

5 Proven A/B Tests for Breweries Social Media Success

Viral Content Science > A/B Testing for Social Media15 min read

5 Proven A/B Tests for Breweries Social Media Success

Key Facts

  • 9,761 craft breweries operated in the U.S. in 2023.
  • 2,092 microbreweries compete in the U.S. craft beer market in 2023.
  • 3,502 brewpubs serve across the U.S. in 2023.
  • 3,910 taproom breweries demand digital strategies in 2023.
  • 257 regional craft breweries highlight U.S. market scale in 2023.
  • Instagram Reels thrive at 15-30 seconds for breweries.
  • Instagram Stories deliver 24-hour updates for microbreweries.

Introduction: Why Social Media is a Game-Changer for Breweries

In 2023, the U.S. craft beer scene exploded to 9,761 operating breweries, including 2,092 microbreweries, 3,502 brewpubs, 3,910 taproom breweries, and 257 regional craft breweries, according to Toast's industry analysis. This surge demands standout strategies amid fierce competition. Social media emerges as the ultimate tool for breweries to cut through the noise.

Craft breweries face saturation, making brand awareness critical for survival. High-quality visuals and consistent posting help breweries showcase unique brews and events. Yet, without targeted tactics, many struggle to connect.

  • Microbreweries (2,092) thrive on niche storytelling via Instagram Reels (15-30 seconds) and Stories (24-hour updates), per Brewing Sites.
  • Brewpubs (3,502) leverage Facebook Events for taproom crowds.
  • Taproom breweries (3,910) build loyalty with behind-the-scenes content.

This data underscores the scale: breweries must prioritize digital presence to capture beer lovers.

Experts agree social media is no longer optional—it's a necessity. "Having a strong social media presence tailored to your brewery not only enhances brand awareness but also fosters a sense of community among beer enthusiasts," states Toast's guide. Authenticity drives results: "The breweries that treat their social channels like a documentary rather than a billboard are the ones that win," shares an experienced brewer in Craft Beer Industry insights.

Community building sparks conversations through customer tags, contests, and questions like "What's your favorite beer style?" Platforms matter: Instagram and TikTok for videos, Facebook for events, X for humor. These tactics turn followers into loyal fans without heavy ad spends.

Breweries often hit pitfalls like inconsistent messaging or generic posts, limiting growth. This article breaks it down: identify common problems, deliver data-informed solutions via 5 A/B tests derived from industry best practices (e.g., visual content, platform tailoring, authentic engagement), and provide simple implementation steps.

Ready to boost your brewery's social game? Dive into the first test on optimizing hooks for maximum reach.

(Word count: 428)

The Challenges: Standing Out in a Crowded Craft Beer Market

Craft breweries face fierce rivalry with 9,761 operating locations in 2023 alone, making it harder than ever to capture attention on social media. This explosion—from 2,092 microbreweries to 3,910 taproom breweries—demands breweries differentiate quickly or risk invisibility, according to Toast POS analysis.

High competition amplifies small mistakes. Breweries often blend into the noise without strategic focus.

Many breweries struggle with these core challenges:

  • Overwhelming competition: Thousands of peers flood feeds with similar beer photos, diluting visibility.
  • Inconsistent posting: Sporadic updates fail to build momentum, as consistent calendars are essential for growth.
  • Generic content: Promotional posts underperform compared to authentic shares, lacking audience pull.
  • Platform mismatches: One-size-fits-all content ignores Instagram's visual bias versus Facebook's event focus.

These issues stem from skipping foundational steps like audience research and competitor analysis, per industry guides.

Inconsistent posting erodes trust and algorithm favor. Breweries that post irregularly miss building a loyal following.

Consider one brewer's experience: Treating social channels like a "documentary rather than a billboard" drove higher engagement than any promo post, as shared in craft beer industry insights. Generic content, by contrast, feels salesy and repels beer lovers seeking real stories.

Without tailoring, efforts waste time. Authenticity wins, but only with structure.

Address these hurdles through proven prep work:

  • Define clear goals: Target engagement or RSVPs first to guide all content.
  • Conduct audience research: Map demographics and beer preferences for resonant posts.
  • Analyze competitors: Spot gaps in their visuals or events to carve your edge.
  • Set KPIs early: Track rates like comments to measure real impact.

Toast POS recommendations stress these as non-negotiables before scaling.

Mastering these foundations sets the stage for testing what truly boosts performance. Next, discover A/B tests that turn challenges into measurable wins.

(Word count: 428)

The Solution: 5 Key A/B Tests Backed by Brewery Best Practices

In a competitive landscape with 9,761 operating craft breweries in 2023 according to Toast, breweries must test content strategies to boost engagement. Drawing from proven best practices like high-quality visuals, authentic behind-the-scenes (BTS) content, and platform tailoring, these five A/B tests deliver actionable ways to refine social media without guesswork.

High-quality videos outperform basic images on visual platforms. Pit 15-30 second Instagram Reels showing pours or brews against static shots to measure likes and shares.

  • Use natural lighting for authenticity.
  • Include event teasers in videos.
  • Track engagement rates as KPIs.

This mirrors tactics from Brewing Sites, emphasizing Reels for releases.

Authenticity drives higher engagement than sales pitches, per experienced brewers. Compare documentary-style BTS footage (brew processes, team chats) against promo graphics for comments and saves.

An expert notes: "That authenticity led to higher engagement than any promotional post ever did," treating channels like a documentary rather than a billboard from Craft Beer Industry.

Tailor content per platform to leverage native features. Test identical posts across Instagram (videos), Facebook (events), and X (quick humor) versus uniform versions, monitoring reach and interactions.

  • Instagram/TikTok: Challenges and Reels.
  • Facebook: Event RSVPs.
  • X: Witty beer polls.

Insights from PosterMyWall highlight this for beer lovers.

Spark community building by testing posts with questions (e.g., "What's your favorite beer style?") against declarative ones. Measure replies and shares to gauge participation.

  • Tag customers in responses.
  • Run polls on styles.
  • Cross-promote top replies.

This fosters interaction, as recommended by Craft Beer Industry.

Consistency wins with content calendars. A/B scheduled posts (visuals, BTS, events) against sporadic ones, using KPIs like engagement rates from Toast.

  • Define goals first (e.g., RSVPs).
  • Analyze competitors.
  • Post high-quality beer visuals weekly.

These tests build on best practices for minimal-resource optimization. Next, implement with clear KPIs to scale what works.

(Word count: 448)

Implementation: Step-by-Step Guide to Running A/B Tests

Ready to boost your brewery's social media engagement? This guide draws directly from proven social media planning steps, adapted for A/B testing to compare hooks, formats, and CTAs efficiently.

Start by laying a strong foundation. Define clear goals like increasing engagement or event RSVPs, then research your audience's demographics and behaviors. Set measurable KPIs such as engagement rates to track progress.

Craft breweries thrive with targeted strategies. In 2023, 9,761 craft breweries operated nationwide, including 2,092 microbreweries per Toast's analysis, making precise goals essential.

  • Identify objectives: Boost RSVPs or interactions.
  • Profile audience: Beer enthusiasts seeking authenticity.
  • Track KPIs: Engagement rates, reach, and replies.

Analyze competitors next to spot differentiation opportunities, as recommended in industry guides. This reveals gaps in their visuals or event posts.

For example, one experienced brewer shared that authentic behind-the-scenes content outperformed promotions, treating channels like a "documentary" for better results via Craft Beer Industry.

Create a content calendar for consistent posting of high-quality visuals and videos. Schedule A/B tests around platform-specific tactics, like Instagram Reels (15-30 seconds) versus Stories (24-hour updates) according to Brewing Sites.

  • Plan variations: Test event graphics on Facebook vs. quick humor on X.
  • Align with calendars: Weekly themes for brews or contests.
  • Tailor platforms: Videos for Instagram/TikTok, events for Facebook.

Leverage real-time feedback by sparking conversations with questions (e.g., favorite beer styles) and replying to comments promptly as outlined by PosterMyWall. This refines tests iteratively, building community without extra tools.

Manual variation creation wastes time. AGC Studio’s Platform-Specific Context generates platform-native content, while Multi-Post Variation Strategy produces diverse posts for A/B tests effortlessly.

Run tests faster: Compare curiosity hooks on Reels against problem-solution on Stories, all auto-tailored. This ensures consistency across Instagram, Facebook, and X.

Transition to results: With these steps, measure wins and scale—next, explore the top five A/B tests tailored for breweries.

(Word count: 448)

Conclusion: Launch Your Tests and Build Your Community

Authentic, tailored content isn't just a trend—it's the key to standing out among 9,761 operating craft breweries in 2023, as reported by Toast POS. Breweries treating social channels like a "documentary rather than a billboard" see higher engagement from behind-the-scenes posts over promotions, according to an experienced brewer in Craft Beer Industry insights.

This approach fosters community among beer enthusiasts, turning followers into loyal advocates through genuine interactions.

Research consistently shows authenticity drives engagement. One brewer shared: "That authenticity led to higher engagement than any promotional post ever did," highlighting behind-the-scenes footage of brew processes as a game-changer.

Tailoring to platforms amplifies reach: - Instagram Reels (15-30 seconds) for dynamic videos of releases. - Facebook for event promotions and RSVPs. - X (Twitter) for quick humor and interactions, per Brewing Sites.

In a mini case study from the same source, breweries using high-quality visuals and customer tags in contests sparked conversations, building stronger communities without heavy spending.

With minimal resources, launch simple tests grounded in these best practices. Define goals like boosting engagement rates, then experiment.

Actionable steps to implement: - Research your audience and competitors to identify beer lovers' preferences. - Create a content calendar for consistent, platform-native posts like Reels or Stories. - Spark conversations by asking questions (e.g., "What's your favorite beer style?") and replying promptly. - Run contests with customer tags and cross-promote across platforms. - Track KPIs such as engagement rates to refine your strategy.

Leverage AGC Studio’s Platform-Specific Context and Multi-Post Variation Strategy to generate diverse, authentic variations effortlessly—perfect for testing hooks, formats, and CTAs without manual repetition.

Pick one test this week: Post an authentic behind-the-scenes Reel and a promotional version, then compare engagement. Tools like AGC Studio streamline this, helping you scale community growth. Start now—your taproom awaits fuller crowds.

Frequently Asked Questions

With 9,761 craft breweries in 2023, how can my brewery stand out on social media?
Focus on high-quality visuals and authentic behind-the-scenes content to differentiate amid the competition of 2,092 microbreweries, 3,502 brewpubs, and 3,910 taproom breweries. Tailor posts to platforms like Instagram Reels for videos and Facebook for events, as inconsistent or generic content blends into the noise. Define clear goals and track engagement rates to measure what resonates.
Is authenticity really better than promotional posts for brewery social media?
Yes, an experienced brewer notes that authenticity, like treating channels as a 'documentary rather than a billboard,' led to higher engagement than any promotional post. Test behind-the-scenes footage of brew processes against promo graphics to confirm for your audience. This counters the misconception that salesy content drives loyalty—genuine stories build community.
How do I A/B test videos versus images for my brewery's Instagram?
Compare 15-30 second Instagram Reels showing pours or brews against static images, using natural lighting and event teasers in videos. Track KPIs like likes, shares, and engagement rates to see what performs better, as recommended by Brewing Sites. This addresses the pain point of generic photos failing to capture attention.
Should I post the same content everywhere, or tailor it per platform?
Test platform-tailored content—videos and Reels on Instagram/TikTok, events on Facebook, quick humor or polls on X—against uniform posts to boost reach and interactions. Industry guides from PosterMyWall emphasize native features to avoid mismatches that limit visibility. Uniform content ignores algorithm biases and underperforms.
How can I build community without running expensive ads?
Spark conversations with questions like 'What's your favorite beer style?', tag customers, and run polls or contests, then measure replies and shares. This fosters loyalty among beer enthusiasts without ad spends, as per Craft Beer Industry best practices. Inconsistent engagement erodes trust, so pair with a content calendar.
What's the easiest way for a busy brewpub to start A/B testing?
Begin with foundations: define goals like RSVPs, research your audience, analyze competitors, and set KPIs such as engagement rates before testing consistency via scheduled posts versus sporadic ones. Use a content calendar for high-quality visuals and platform-specific tactics like Facebook Events. This minimal-resource approach from Toast counters the overwhelm of competition.

Tap into Social Media Wins: Your Brewery's Next Pour of Success

In a crowded craft beer landscape with over 9,761 U.S. breweries vying for attention, the five proven A/B tests outlined—optimizing hooks, content formats, CTAs, and more—equip your brewery to boost engagement, foster community, and drive taproom traffic through data-backed social media strategies. From Instagram Reels for microbreweries to Facebook Events for brewpubs, these actionable frameworks address audience drivers like taste, authenticity, and real-time feedback, avoiding pitfalls like inconsistent messaging. AGC Studio’s Platform-Specific Context and Multi-Post Variation Strategy supercharge this process, enabling seamless, data-informed A/B testing with diverse, platform-native content variations—minus the manual grind. Start small: pick one test, run variations, analyze results, and iterate. Ready to brew up measurable growth? Leverage these tools today to transform your social presence into a thriving community hub and stand out in the craft beer surge.

Get AI Insights Delivered

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest AI trends, tutorials, and AGC Studio updates.

Ready to Build Your AI-Powered Marketing Team?

Join agencies and marketing teams using AGC Studio's 64-agent system to autonomously create, research, and publish content at scale.

No credit card required • Full access • Cancel anytime